Two ways to shop:

Shop from home: Browse our selection online and have your perfect dress delivered right to your door.

Local to Utah? Schedule a private appointment to try on dresses in person and rent or purchase your favorites

Schedule an Appointment

Casual Dresses

View all
Smocked Bodycon Maxi Dress

Smocked Bodycon Maxi Dress

Smocked Bodycon Maxi Dress

$70.00
Sale price  $70.00 Regular price 
Denim Round Neck Midi Dress

Denim Round Neck Midi Dress

Denim Round Neck Midi Dress

$64.00
Sale price  $64.00 Regular price 
Plaid Flowy Tiered Midi Dress

Plaid Flowy Tiered Midi Dress

Plaid Flowy Tiered Midi Dress

$48.00
Sale price  $48.00 Regular price 
CD07309-Botanical Print Babydoll Midi Dress

CD07309-Botanical Print Babydoll Midi Dress

CD07309-Botanical Print Babydoll Midi Dress

$60.00
Sale price  $60.00 Regular price 

Special Occasion Dresses- Floor Length

View all
Shimmering gown

Shimmering gown

Shimmering gown

$129.00
Sale price  $129.00 Regular price 
Mermaid Lace Dress

Mermaid Lace Dress

Mermaid Lace Dress

$115.00
Sale price  $115.00 Regular price 
Lace Bodice Floor Length Gown

Lace Bodice Floor Length Gown

Lace Bodice Floor Length Gown

$129.00
Sale price  $129.00 Regular price 
Satin Corset Ballgown

Satin Corset Ballgown

Satin Corset Ballgown

$218.00
Sale price  $218.00 Regular price  $0.00

Special Occasion Dresses - Short & Midi

View all
3D Floral Textrued Short Dress

3D Floral Textrued Short Dress

3D Floral Textrued Short Dress

$60.00
Sale price  $60.00 Regular price 
Mini Lace And Tulle Cap Sleeve Dress With Belt

Mini Lace And Tulle Cap Sleeve Dress With Belt

Mini Lace And Tulle Cap Sleeve Dress With Belt

$95.00
Sale price  $95.00 Regular price  $110.00
Lace & Chiffon Rhinestone Belt Dress

Lace & Chiffon Rhinestone Belt Dress

Lace & Chiffon Rhinestone Belt Dress

$109.00
Sale price  $109.00 Regular price 
Sweetheart Embroidered Embellished Short Dress

Sweetheart Embroidered Embellished Short Dress

Sweetheart Embroidered Embellished Short Dress

$139.00
Sale price  $139.00 Regular price  $0.00

Previously Rented Dresses - Floor Length

View all
Ivy City Athena Dress

Ivy City Athena Dress

Ivy City Athena Dress

$99.00
Sale price  $99.00 Regular price  $198.00
Glitter Metallic Cap Sleeve A-line Dress

Glitter Metallic Cap Sleeve A-line Dress

Glitter Metallic Cap Sleeve A-line Dress

$100.00
Sale price  $100.00 Regular price  $200.00
Long Stretch Satin Three-Quarter Sleeve Sheath

Long Stretch Satin Three-Quarter Sleeve Sheath

Long Stretch Satin Three-Quarter Sleeve Sheath

$94.00
Sale price  $94.00 Regular price  $189.00
Sequin Print Maxi Long Evening Dress with Cap Sleeve

Sequin Print Maxi Long Evening Dress with Cap Sleeve

Sequin Print Maxi Long Evening Dress with Cap Sleeve

$45.00
Sale price  $45.00 Regular price  $90.00

Previously Rented Dresses - Short & Midi

View all
JessaKae Yellow Swiss Dot Dress

JessaKae Yellow Swiss Dot Dress

JessaKae Yellow Swiss Dot Dress

$70.00
Sale price  $70.00 Regular price  $148.00
Bohme Pink Floral Organza Puff Sleeve Square Neck Dress

Bohme Pink Floral Organza Puff Sleeve Square Neck Dress

Bohme Pink Floral Organza Puff Sleeve Square Neck Dress

$40.00
Sale price  $40.00 Regular price  $68.00
Lavender Baby Doll Dress

Lavender Baby Doll Dress

Lavender Baby Doll Dress

$45.00
Sale price  $45.00 Regular price  $74.00
Piper & Scoot Floral Embroidered Square Neck Tulle Midi Dress

Piper & Scoot Floral Embroidered Square Neck Tulle Midi Dress

Piper & Scoot Floral Embroidered Square Neck Tulle Midi Dress

$45.00
Sale price  $45.00 Regular price  $98.00

Our Story

Modern Modesty began with my daughter.

When she started high school a few years ago we excitedly searched for her first dance dress. We looked for something she loved that was also modest. We quickly realized how difficult that could be.

As a fashion design graduate who had worked in the prom and bridal industry, I decided to do something about it.

I started collecting beautiful modest formal dresses to rent for proms and special occasions. I've been doing this locally for the past three years which has been even more fun and rewarding than I imagined! Recently my daughter prepared to serve a mission in Paraguay and we faced a similar challenge—finding modest, comfortable dresses she could wear every day that were affordable.

That experience inspired Modern Modesty to grow beyond renting and selling formalwear just locally. Today we offer thoughtfully selected dresses for church, everyday life, special occasions, and sister missionaries—so women can spend less time searching and more time feeling beautiful and confident.

-Karen